My friend told me about the other art store I really like in New Jersey. Pearl Paint is a huge art supply warehouse/supermarket with prices that are competitive with Utrecht (maybe even a little less expensive). They have some really nice creamy pastels (Caran d'Ache Neopastels) not available at Utrecht.

675 US 1 S
Iselin, NJ 08830
(732) 634-9400

http://www.pearlpaint.com/